The FTC’s guide to its mail order rule asks who is liable when a fulfillment house or drop shipper causes a violation. The answer is the seller. The store solicits the order. It sets the shipping promise and picks the fulfillment house. The duty stays with whoever solicited the order.
This is a US rule. It covers order sales “in or affecting commerce” as the FTC Act defines the term, so a store outside the US should check whether its American orders fall under it.
Liability is where the dropshipping supplier red flags matter most. A supplier’s habits become the store’s legal exposure. The 30-day clock starts when a properly completed order arrives, meaning payment plus the details needed to ship.
A handling time nobody has written down is a weak basis for a shipping promise
The Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule requires a store to have a reasonable basis for the shipping time it advertises. Advertise none, and the store must expect to ship within 30 days. The FTC’s business guide to the rule defines shipment as the moment the goods are physically in the carrier’s possession. So the supplier’s handling days sit inside your promise. A supplier who says “usually quick” and gives no carrier has given you nothing.
Slow is not the same as bad. Take the numbers. Shopify’s AliExpress guide publishes ePacket at 7 to 15 days and China Post Registered Small Parcel at 7 to 30. It cites a Narvar study in which 70% of surveyed shoppers call an accurate delivery date “very important,” ranking it ahead of speed. A store that quotes three weeks and ships in three weeks has kept its promise.
Get the handling time and the carrier in writing before the product goes live. Add the carrier’s range to the handling days when you write the page. Duties, tracking and carrier liability on parcels that cross a border are covered in the guide to international dropshipping.
A silent supplier leaves the store with a notice that says “date unknown”, or a refund
When an order cannot ship on time, the store must offer the buyer a choice. Wait, or cancel for a refund. The notice cannot arrive later than the time you promised, or 30 days if you promised none. The FTC guide sets the notice deadline at no later than that.
Shopify’s guide puts it in one line: if a supplier does not respond before you order, avoid relying on them for customer orders. The FTC staff guide lists what the agency weighs when deciding whether to recommend enforcement, and part of it is how the merchant manages its fulfillment house. Did the merchant contract with it to require compliance, or at least prompt reports of problems? Did it place seeded orders to time the house? Did it monitor customer complaints for unusual surges?
Missing the notice can be expensive. In April 2020 Fashion Nova agreed to pay $9.3 million to settle FTC charges. The agency said the retailer promised “Fast Shipping,” “2-Day Shipping” and “Expect Your Items Quick!” while regularly failing to ship on time. Customers were not offered the chance to cancel, it said, and gift cards went out where refunds were due.
Under the rule a refund cannot be store credit, a voucher or scrip. Once the promised window is blown and the supplier will not confirm shipment, the store has no revised date it can stand behind. It can say the date is unknown, with the reason, or cancel and refund.
A low price is one of the dropshipping supplier red flags until the whole ledger is added up
Price needs a caveat. A supplier’s price means little alone. It matters against what the sale has to cover. Shopify’s guide says the retail price must cover product cost, shipping, duties, taxes, payment fees, returns, support and marketing. A cheaper supplier that charges for handling or ships slowly enough to trigger refunds can cost more than the one who looked expensive on the first quote.
Comparing the same item across several suppliers catches the extreme cases. It misses the supplier whose low price depends on corners the customer sees only on delivery day. Catching that takes a sample. Shopify recommends a test order before committing, so you judge shipping time and quality as a customer would.
Keep the evidence. Records are not required, the FTC guide says, but a seller that cannot document its compliance systems bears the burden of proving it complies. A dated test order, the supplier’s written handling time and a saved copy of the delay notice template are small files. Note the date each test order reaches the carrier and keep the note with the handling time.
Frequently asked questions
What must a delay notice to a customer contain?
A definite revised shipping date, or a statement that you cannot give one. It must also say the customer can cancel and get a full, prompt refund, and give a way to cancel at your expense, such as a website or toll-free number. If you cannot give a date, add the reason for the delay.
Does the 50-day shipping period apply to a card order?
No. The rule allows 50 days instead of 30 only when the buyer applies to the seller for credit to pay for the merchandise. An ordinary card payment on a store checkout leaves you with the time you advertised or, if you advertised none, 30 days.
Which records show a dropshipper followed the Mail Order Rule?
The FTC lists the date you received each order, the content and date of any delay notice, the date a cancellation came in, the shipment date, and the date of any refund and the merchandise it covered. In an FTC action, a seller that cannot document its compliance systems bears the burden of proving it had a reasonable basis for its shipping promise.
